How Do I Know If My Stone Is Good For Baking Cookies?

Apr 09, 2024

Let's Talk Baking Stones

Stones were invented for pizzas, not for cookies. It must have been some serendipitous discovery that it even works for something with such a high butter content. As long as I have been baking cookies I have baked on a stone. I like it because the cookies bake so evenly because the back of each cookie looks as good as the front, and I don't have some cookies getting too done while others on the same stone are too soft.


Almost everybody has at least one stone. Made popular by those kitchen shows you host right in your own home, I have found that almost every kitchen has at least one stone for pizza if not for baking.  Being a bargain hunter, I have to plead guilty to buying several substandard stones (which I didn't learn were NOT such a bargain after baking on them).


You can pick up a stone at Walmart, Kohl's, Williams Sonoma, Kitchen Collection, and Amazon.


Having been invented for pizza, the thick crust is there to prevent anything from dripping through the stone so it really wouldn't matter if the stone is porous or not. But, when you put cookie dough on a stone, porousness matters. 


Cookie dough that begins with a pound of butter will bake beautifully and evenly on a stone when heated to 325 degrees. However, if you place your cookies on a porous stone that was intended to come into contact with pizza crust, you stand the chance of the butter dripping through, puddling up in the bottom of your oven, setting off your fire alarms, bringing firemen and firetrucks to the house and neighbors standing in the street. (or so I've heard).


Recently, I embarked on a quest to find the best baking surface for cookies. I knew it would need to be a stone and it couldn't be porous. So, I googled up every stone on the internet I could find that was made in America and ordered one of each. All those stones arrived and I commenced using the scientific method to bake on each one until I could find the PERFECT stone surface for baking.


It is crazy that they all look alike! Some have handles, some are round, some are rectangle, some are square but the shape and size are the only things that appear to make a difference.....Then you bake on them.


If you lift the cookies off your stone and a little bit of cookie remains stuck to the stone, you have a substandard stone. That cookie tried to drip down into the pores of the backing surface but was unsuccessful.


If you lift the cookies off the stone and you can see the shape of the cookies you just baked, that butter dripped down into the pores in the shape of the Grinch and it stayed in that stone. Expect for that stone to eventually smell like rancid oil, especially when it gets hot.


If you immerse the stone in the sink because you want to clean it off, if the stone wicks up water, and mixes with that butter that is still inside the stone, when it gets dry, it is going to start growing a whole new science fair project on it. YUCK! (I keep this stone only to show my students what NOT to buy. No cookies have been baked on it since the mold started growing.)


So what does a good stone look like?


How will you know if the stone you have is a good surface for baking cookies? Test it out.


You don't typically get firetrucks until you have baked several rounds of cookies on it.


This is my new favorite stone. It is 13" round. Yes, you can also bake pizza on it but I am personally a segregationist so I like to keep garlic and sugar apart. It is not porous so all of that butter stays in the cookie. I have baked at least 25 rounds of cookies on this stone and you see it looks the same as when I took it out of the box.


When I get a brand new stone, I rub it with a butter wrapper the first time, then after that, I never season it anymore.


The cookies do that for me. This stone will eventually turn a little darker but not a whole lot because we are not baking on a really high temperature. To clean, rinse with water and dry.This stone is made by American Bakeware (americanbakeware.com).


The 13" is a real bargain compared to the home show.


In fact, I can get almost two stones for the price of one rectangle. I have these available if you are local. If not, you can order online.

As always, if you like baking on metal, they are your cookies; do what you like. But if you are looking to up your cookie game, try baking on a great quality stone.

By Maya Infosoft 28 Sep, 2024
If you’ve ever admired beautifully decorated cookies and wished you could create your own edible masterpieces, Cookie Nip Studio Kitchen is here to help! Our online cookie decorating classes make it easier than ever to develop your skills, whether you’re a complete beginner or looking to refine your techniques. With the flexibility of online learning and expert instruction, our classes offer everything you need to master the art of cookie decorating. Why Choose Online Cookie Decorating Classes? At Cookie Nip Studio Kitchen, we understand that life can be busy, which is why we offer online cookie classes that you can take from the comfort of your home. Our online classes are perfect for anyone who wants to learn at their own pace. Whether you’re balancing a busy work schedule, taking care of a family, or just prefer learning from your kitchen, online classes offer unmatched flexibility. One of the key benefits of online cookie decorating classes is that you can revisit the lessons as many times as you need. This means you’ll be able to pause, rewind, and practice each step of the process until you’re confident in your skills. With detailed video tutorials and step-by-step instructions, you’ll have all the tools you need to create beautifully decorated cookies. What You’ll Learn in Our Online Cookie Classes Our online classes cover a wide range of techniques, from basic decorating skills to advanced designs. You’ll learn everything from piping and flooding to creating intricate patterns and textures. Whether you’re interested in designing custom cookies for special occasions or simply want to improve your decorating abilities, our classes have something for everyone. In the introductory sessions, you’ll learn the fundamentals of cookie decorating, including how to create the perfect royal icing consistency and how to use different types of piping tips for various effects. As you progress through the course, you’ll move on to more advanced techniques, such as creating detailed designs, layering colors, and adding finishing touches that will make your cookies truly stand out. Not only will you develop your decorating skills, but you’ll also learn how to make your cookies taste as good as they look. Our online classes cover tips for baking the perfect cookies that are sturdy enough for decorating but still soft and delicious. By the end of the course, you’ll be able to confidently create your own custom cookies for any occasion. Who Can Benefit from Our Online Cookie Decorating Classes? Our online cookie classes are designed for everyone, whether you’re a total beginner or an experienced baker looking to refine your techniques. We cater to a variety of skill levels, so you can choose the class that best suits your experience and goals. If you’re someone who loves the idea of creating personalized treats for events, our classes will give you the skills you need to design custom cookies that are sure to impress. You’ll learn how to create cookies for birthdays, weddings, holidays, and more, using designs that reflect your unique style. For those located in Atlanta, our online classes provide the same high-quality instruction as our in-person offerings. And while you may not be able to attend a class at our studio, you can still create custom cookies in Atlanta or anywhere you’re based, using the techniques you’ve learned online. Why Cookie Decorating is the Perfect Creative Outlet Cookie decorating is more than just a fun activity—it’s a creative outlet that allows you to express yourself in a unique and edible form. Whether you’re decorating cookies for a family celebration, a gift, or just for fun, the possibilities are endless. You’ll be able to experiment with colors, designs, and techniques to create something that is truly one-of-a-kind. Not only is cookie decorating a great way to relieve stress, but it’s also a fantastic way to make memories. Invite friends and family to join you in a decorating session, either in person or virtually, and enjoy the process of creating something beautiful together. Start Your Cookie Decorating Journey Today At Cookie Nip Studio Kitchen, we believe that anyone can master the art of cookie decorating with the right guidance and tools. Our online cookie decorating classes are designed to be fun, engaging, and accessible for learners of all skill levels. If you’ve ever wanted to create custom cookies that look just as good as they taste, now is the perfect time to start. Sign up for one of our classes today, and you’ll be well on your way to becoming a cookie decorating pro. Our online classes make it easy to bring the art of cookie decorating into your home. Get ready to impress your friends and family with your newfound skills and delicious creations!
09 Apr, 2024
It's A Sweet Life!
09 Apr, 2024
The First Shipment of Cookie Nip
09 Apr, 2024
Let's Talk Cookie Cutters
09 Apr, 2024
We made Dr Seuss Custom Sugar Cookies!
09 Apr, 2024
Got Groundhog Cookies?
09 Apr, 2024
Come check us out!
09 Apr, 2024
People are always asking me this question and I typically say, "A week!" I need to rethink that answer. Don't be ridiculous. These cookies don't ever hang around long enough to actually go stale, but I have never put it to the REAL test. When I returned to my office after Christmas, I found a couple of cookies that didn't make it to their destinations before we left for the holidays, and they were sitting on my conference table. Right as I started to throw them in the trash, that same old question resonated in my head.  These cookies were baked the week of December 10 and were left in my office from December 15 until now. They were sealed in the bags using the heat sealer we all love so no air was getting to them. I noticed that the red color eventually bled a little into the white brim of the hat and one eye was squished. Just before raking them into the trash, I decided to open one and taste a little crumb just to see (in the interest of science, of course) just HOW stale they were.
09 Apr, 2024
Happy New Year Cookies!
09 Apr, 2024
Let's Talk Baking Stones
More Posts
Share by: